Question:Minehead Co has commissioned a report from an independent specialist which had indicated that mineral reserves at a quarry are 50% higher than was previously thought. The company proposes to adjust the amortisation rate to reflect the new estimate in its accounts and the effect will be material.
  What action should the auditor normally take?
  A. Confirm that it is reasonable to accept the estimate and ensure that it is appropriately disclosed in the accounts.
  B. Confirm that it is reasonable to accept the estimate, ensure it is appropriately disclosed in the accounts AND indicate in the audit report that his opinion is subject to his reliance upon a management expert.
  C. Commission an auditor expert report to confirm the general findings before considering the matter further.
  D. Advise that, because of the subjective nature of any estimate of this kind, the revised value can be disclosed in the notes but should not be incorporated in the accounts.
  The correct answer is: Confirm that it is reasonable to accept the estimate and ensure that it is appropriately disclosed in the accounts.
  解析The auditor should confirm that it is reasonable to accept the estimate and ensure that it is properly disclosed. The auditor should assess the management expert's competence and objectivity before placing reliance on them, there is no need to commission a separate report. In addition ISA 620 Using the work of an auditor's expert states that no reference should be made to the work of the expert in the audit report.